India's Muslims: a community in ferment
By M R Narayan
Swamy New Delhi, Sep 3 (IANS) India's
Muslim community, the world's second largest Islamic population, is in ferment.
There is widespread disappointment, a sense of helplessness and some anger. But
there is also the zeal to surge ahead, the dream of being equal partners in the
nation's destiny. Sixty years after they cast their lot with Hindu-majority
India, rejecting the newly born Pakistan, the millions of Indian Muslims - and
the lives they lead - are under scrutiny like never before due to growing Islamist
militancy globally and a perceived radicalization at home of some of the younger
ones. India's 140 million Muslims, the largest religious minority, have
scored many and remarkable successes since independence in 1947. Some of the most
popular icons in various fields, from national life to cinema to arts and sports,
are Muslim - led by president A.P.J. Abdul Kalam and the richest man Azim Premji,
the head of software giant Wipro. But the wealth and knowledge disparity
is perhaps much more pronounced among Muslims than among other minority communities
in secular and pluralist India. The community occupies the lowest rung
in development index. Its literacy rate is poor. It has low presence in private
and public sector jobs and minimal in the highest echelons of bureaucracy. All
these add to a feeling that they are discriminated against. To cap it all,
Muslims - mainly the poor - are at the receiving end in most outbreaks of communal
violence. And every community leader and others who spoke to IANS say the two
events that have caused maximum disappointment bordering on frenzy are the 1992
razing of the Babri mosque and the 2002 Gujarat violence. This, coupled
with militancy in parts of the Islamic world, has cast a shadow on Indian Muslims.
Gujarat in particular has led to - even according to Indian security agencies
- the frustrated young, albeit still only in small numbers, to avenge the "humiliation"
of their community. In the process, officials admit, that Islamic extremist
outfits supported by Pakistan are drawing recruits from among Indian Muslims,
a development that is dangerous. Only days ago, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh
urged Islamic clerics here to play a pro-active role to douse the flames of anger
in the community. "Many socio-economic problems Indian Muslims face
are the same as faced by others. But there are other issues that affect only them,"
says Intizar Naeem of the Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, a Muslim body set up in 1941. Among
others, he lists the step-motherly treatment to Urdu, the mother tongue of most
Muslims in northern India, attempts to undo the autonomous character of educational
institutions founded by Muslims, attacks on the Muslim Personal Law, harassment
of Muslims after terror acts, caricaturing of Muslims as terrorists, and insinuations
that mosques and 'madrassas' are up to no good. But the Mumbai-educated
Naeem, 62, gives the larger view: "Hindus and Muslims enjoy excellent relations,
and at all levels. From villages to towns, there are cordial relations. And south
Indian Muslims are better off. However, problems are cropping up even there." Other
Muslims, young and old, more or less agree. And they underline that India is truly
a secular country, whatever the shortcomings. "Not 100 percent but
110 percent India is secular," asserts Zarir Ansari, a resident of Guhawati.
"I blame half-baked mullahs who give sermons in mosques and distort Islam." Adds
Nawaz Deobandi, 50, a Hindustani poet who runs educational institutions in Muzaffarnagar
in Uttar Pradesh: "India is the best place for Muslims. Yes, there are roadblocks
but they can be overcome." Anger against "uneducated Imams"
- as many put it - is common among younger educated Muslims. Said one college
student in New Delhi: "The problem is people think we follow what the Imams
say. Of course we don't!" Ansari's 84-year-old father makes a widely
shared point: "If I find those involved in the Mumbai (train) blasts, I will
kill them. I don't care if they are Muslims. Those who did this are terrorists.
But to view all Muslims as terrorists and look at those with beards and skullcaps
as 'enemies' is not on." He asks: "When there was terror in Gujarat,
did we look at Hindus in general with a different pair of eyes? We did not club
the entire Hindu community as our enemy. We knew that only a fringe was involved." Mazhar
Hussain, a social activist in Hyderabad, says the radicalization of Indian Muslim
is essentially an urban phenomenon, limited in spread, and linked to the Middle
East conflict and the targeting of Islam by the West. "As far as our
country is concerned, Kashmir has not made the Indian Muslim radical. But the
Babri Masjid demolition and the Gujarat violence contributed a lot to Muslim hotheads
to exhort the youth towards extremism," he said. "Still, only
a minuscule group is attracted to this thinking. To the poor, making two ends
meet is the biggest challenge. The middle class is getting more and more career-oriented." Added
Rizwanul Haq, a final year degree student: "There is a major difference in
the thinking and attitude of Muslims in south and north India. In the south, Muslims
have been better educated and well off. This reflects their thinking on social
and religious issues." Qari Mohammed Usman, the Naib Mohtamin (assistant
administrator), of Darul Uloom, India's oldest and largest madrassa, defends the
rapid spread of Islamic seminaries, arguing that more of them were needed. He
doesn't agree with critics who argue that the seminaries create insular Muslims. Almost
all Muslims regret that despite centuries of interaction, there is a communication
gap between Hindus and Muslims. Many Muslims are unaware of the finer points of
Hindu religion and its ethos and vice-versa. An average Hindu has no idea of Ulemas
and Imams, and who can give a 'fatwa' and who cannot. Said Azam Khan, a
successful businessman: "This is reflected in the way (most Hindu journalists)
deal with sensitive Muslim issues. This reinforces stereotypes and widens the
gap between the two communities." Tales of discrimination against Muslims
abound. A Muslim journalist complains how difficult it is now to get a house on
rent, particularly if one is new to a city. Adil Siddiqui, a retired central
government employee who now lives in Deoband, says one of his sons, Mohammed Arif,
now 32, passed the written test to get into the Indian Space and Research Organisation
(ISRO) after securing a mechanical engineering degree with high marks. "Believe
it or not, just before his interview, he heard an officer remark: 'Things
have changed since 1992, and these people (Muslims) keep coming for jobs here'."
Arif didn't get the job. But across India, despite the many problems, Muslim
leaders say the community is forging ahead. Large numbers are doing exceedingly
well. The 1992 Babri mosque razing led to major churnings. The dominant consensus
was it was important to concentrate on education. That process continues. More
and more Muslim women, even in smaller towns, are going to schools and colleges.
Although a Muslim political party has come up in Assam and two have been formed
in Uttar Pradesh, most Muslims swear by secular national parties. Observes
Nawaz Deobandi, whose dream is to open a women's university one day: "This
is why there should be no riots. If one Muslim is killed, if his house is burnt,
if his shop is destroyed, the loser is India, not just that Muslim."
|