August 26 , 2006            
            
The degeneration of India's political class

By Amulya Ganguli

Thursday's shocking events in the Indian parliament when some MPs abused one another in vile language, hurled a microphone and nearly came to blows exposed the dark side of the country's much vaunted electoral politics as never before.

Till now, such rowdy conduct had taken place in some state legislatures but not in parliament, which had generally set a higher standard notwithstanding frequent noisy disruptions and walkouts. But the latest incident showed that the thin line that had so far separated this august body from the more unruly state assemblies is gradually vanishing.

India has always been proud of its thriving democracy, which sees popular verdicts being delivered at various levels throughout the year from the village panchayats to urban municipalities to state legislatures and, finally, to parliament in New Delhi.

But during this process the country has chosen to turn a blind eye to the nature of the churning which occurs in the political arena, throwing up elements whose influence in their constituencies depends more on the fear they generate than on the respect they earn.

Over the years, the dominance of these candidates has come to be known as the criminalization of politics, denoting a severe lowering of the standards of behaviour expected from the elected representatives of the people.

It was this degeneration of the political atmosphere that was on display Thursday in the Lok Sabha, the lower house of parliament. Not surprisingly, among the protagonists who exchanged unprintable abuses were Janata Dal-United MP Prabhunath Singh, who was subsequently accused by Railway Minister Lalu Prasad of being guilty of 40 murders - all of them of upper caste Rajputs.

Prabhunath Singh's opponent in the ugly melee was Lalu Prasad's notorious brother-in-law Sadhu Yadav, against whom a non-bailable warrant is pending. It may not have been a coincidence that all these 'honourable' MPs belong to Bihar, the state that sank to the lowest depths in nearly all indices of development and law and order when Lalu Prasad was chief minister.

The Indian public is used to seeing scenes of disturbance in parliament because of the live telecast of the proceedings. On Thursday, however, they missed the most egregious of the incidents as the telecast was abruptly stopped as soon as Speaker Somnath Chatterjee adjourned the house and walked out after failing to restore order.

But the groups of school children who were in the visitors' galleries before being herded out expressed their shock and dismay that grown-up people could behave in such a disgraceful manner.

It doesn't take great wisdom to see that such reprehensible conduct can be eradicated if the political class shows a greater willingness to remove those with a criminal background from their midst.

According to one estimate, 72 MPs out of a total of 542 have dubious antecedents, and so do as many as 700 members of legislative assemblies (MLAs) out of 4,000 in the states. Nor are the politicians unaware of the various proposals made to eliminate this menace by the Election Commission and the Law Commission.

One of the proposals is to stop a candidate from contesting if a charge-sheet in a criminal case has been framed against him in a court of law, thereby suggesting that there is a prima facie case against him.

But all the politicians from the left to the right of the political spectrum have resolutely set their face against such steps to cleanse the system on the grounds that no one can be considered guilty unless convicted by a court.

But, as is known, such convictions are extremely difficult to obtain because the politicians, who may be criminals themselves or retain anti-social elements in their camps, can easily terrorize any potential witness to their wrong deeds against testifying before a magistrate.

The reason for the entry of an increasing number of these muscle men, as they are called, in Indian politics is, first, the reluctance of decent people from respectable families to contest because of the bad name the profession has earned over the years.

Secondly, the proliferation of parties has meant that enormous resources in terms of money and manpower are needed during elections. These requirements have grown exponentially because of the large number of elections that are fought nowadays to the state legislatures and parliament because of the instability of the governments.

No party, therefore, can afford to tread the straight and narrow path. Instead, they have to increasingly depend on questionable sources of income and unsavoury characters to conduct the campaign that includes, more often than not, the tactics of intimidating the voters.

Hence, the presence of 'tainted' ministers like Lalu Yadav, the prime accused in the Bihar fodder scam, and Shibu Soren, the coal minister who has a murder charge pending against him. And such is their indispensability to the parties in power that even a prime minister like Manmohan Singh, known for his personal integrity, has no option but to retain them in his cabinet.

The only possible solution is for an intensive campaign in the media, especially the increasingly influential visual one, to highlight the incidents, such as the one Thursday, and provide detailed information about the criminal backgrounds of the MPs and MLAs.

Perhaps only then will the political class be shamed into taking corrective steps. Otherwise, they will happily let the bad apples remain in their midst.



Karan Johar's sensitive exploration of taboo territory

Shah Rukh Khan
By Subhash K. Jha

Sometimes you hold a film close to your heart not because the characters embrace you, but for the opposite reason.


I was bowled over by Shah Rukh: Abhishek Bachchan


Abhishek Bachchan
By Subhash K. Jha

Mumbai, Aug 11 (IANS) Abhishek Bachchan has two major releases lined up for August, "Kabhi Alvida Naa Kehna" (KANK) and "Umrao Jaan", and they are vastly different from each other. But he is not worried.


Ram Gopal Verma says he can't handle Shah Rukh's persona

By Subhash K. Jha

Mumbai, Aug 4 (IANS) Ram Gopal Varma has decided to make "Sholay" with Amitabh Bachchan instead of "Time Machine" with Shah Rukh Khan, because he thinks the latter's youthful image doesn't fit his kind of dark and intense cinema.

Can Ram Gopal Verma keep quiet about what Karan Johar does?

By Subhash K. Jha

"In my opinion Ram Gopal Varma is one of the finest filmmakers of our country. His 'Satya', 'Company' and 'Sarkar' make a trilogy of terrific gangster films. When he has so much work on hand I wonder why he keeps obsessing with what I do! I know he doesn't respect my work. But could he please keep quiet about what I do?"


'Omkara', a web of crime, deceit and tender love



By Subhash K. Jha

Vishal Bharadwaj comes up with a gallery of virile characters who jump out of their literary antecedents and do a dance of crime-driven dynamics on the nozzle of their country-made guns.

Watch Omkara trailer

 

Finding Magic Somewhere Under the Pool in 'Lady in the Water'

By Manohla Dargis, The New York Times


 
 

BUSINESS

India needs to immediately stem the rot in call center thefts

Ranbaxy notches up yet another approval in U.S.

GE, NTPC and Maharashtra's power woes

POLITICS

Gujarat's Narendra Modi desperate to recast image

India's communist flexing muscles over Iran and economic reform

ECONOMY

India economy posts 8.1 percent growth

China is using India as a dumping ground

Rich are richer, poor are poorer

SCIENCE

India's mediocre scientific establishment

Ayurveda moves a step closer to modern testing methods


HEALTH

Don't drink water in Bangladesh

Don't drink water in India too


ARTS

Indian painters rake in millions in New York auctions

MOVIES

Salman Khan bares more than his chest

The Inner World of Shah Rukh Khan



THEATER

Marathi theater versus Gujarati theater--Craft versus Commerce?




DIPLOMACY

Sri Lanka calls for more Indian help in battling aftermath of tsunami

Karzai-Musharraf spat continues

Nepal uses Chinese shoulder to aim its gun at India

FEATURES

Veil is off, gloves are on

Smelling rain, Goa pulls out its green thumb

India's last mughal a saint in Myanmar

SPORTS

Tendulkar contemplates future from sidelines


Did Tiger really prey on the black buck?

Sania Mirza wins by losing

TECHNOLOGY

Wallet on mobile phone

Pakistan tries to catch up with India in IT; but can it ever?

India and egovernance

TRAVEL

Lost in Ladakh

Bhutan sends out selective invitation

Sri Lanka's captures tourists with Kandy's old world charms

BOOKS

The Spice Route: A History

Sikandar Chowk Park


FASHION & STYLE

Is Indian fashion really going anywhere?

The enduring mystic of the sari

EDUCATION

India's factory of engineers: How good they really are?



BACK TO TOP